Israeli army’s ‘innovative methods’ held to very different standard

Article content

The late, great Sunday Times writer Marie Colvin said it best: War correspondents send back the first draft of history.

Advertisement 2

Article content

Colvin was assassinated by the Syrian regime in 2012. She, more than most, knew how difficult it is to ascertain the truth in the chaos and wreckage of wartime. The first casualty of war is indeed truth, as everyone knows.’

Article content

During Israel’s overdue and righteous war against the murderous cult that is Hamas, many re-learned this lesson the hard way. Remember that hospital in Gaza, the one that Israel supposedly destroyed back in October, purportedly killing 500 innocent Palestinians in the process?

Well, they didn’t destroy the hospital or kill 500 people. The hospital is still standing and 500 bodies have yet to be produced by the Hamas-controlled health authority. However, no less than the New York Times blamed Israel on its front page, under a screaming headline.

Advertisement 3

Article content

And they were wrong. As the Times was subsequently forced to admit: “[Our] coverage — and the prominence it received in a headline, news alert and social media channels — relied too heavily on claims by Hamas and did not make clear that those claims could not immediately be verified. The report left readers with an incorrect impression about what was known and how credible the account was.”

Recommended from Editorial

Incorrect is a bit of an understatement. When you wrongly accuse a country of a massive war crime on your front page, you need to clearly and unambiguously apologize. You also need to do something else: Never take the word of Hamas. In particular, don’t take the word of Hamas or its agencies when assessing what is happening in the war in Gaza.

Article content

Advertisement 4

Article content

Edward N. Luttwak didn’t. Luttwak has been a war correspondent and soldier himself. In a piece published this week in Tablet magazine, Luttwak carefully analyzed Israel’s conduct in the war so far. His conclusion: “Israel’s very innovative methods to surveil, penetrate and destroy Hamas tunnels have been markedly and unexpectedly successful. But the constraints placed on Israel’s combat operations have been very severe and a major impediment to its fight.”

Among those constraints, of course, is that Israel is always held to a different standard. The aforementioned Syrian regime can slaughter 110,000 Muslims in 2015, many of them children, and the keffiyeh-clad gen-Z protesters in the West won’t chant a thing. About Israel, of course, they’ll scream bloody murder.

Advertisement 5

Article content

And that’s even when murder has not taken place. As Luttwak wrote, “The Israeli army remains wedded to the British method of intensive and prolonged individual instruction for its soldiers before their in-unit training, so that nobody enters Gaza without at least a full year’s worth of combat instruction, much more than their American counterparts had in Vietnam.”

That has kept Israeli troop casualties to a shockingly small number: Less than 300. Said Luttwak: “Not in the thousands suggested by the beribboned skeptics who were gleefully echoed by the malevolent, but under 300 as of this writing. In other words, only a very, very small number, given the magnitude of the forces involved on both sides and the exceptional complexity of the battlefield.”

Advertisement 6

Article content

Nor does Luttwak accept the wild numbers coming out of Hamas when calculating civilian deaths: “Contrary to accusations that only expensively educated U.S. college students could possibly believe, Israeli soldiers do not deliberately kill innocent civilians going about their business.”

Meanwhile, he said, thousands of trained Hamas fighters have been slain. The Israeli battlefield victories have been “exceptional,” he said.

How has Israel accomplished all of this? Three ways, Luttwak said.


We apologize, but this video has failed to load.

One, Israeli troops did not simply charge into the maze of Hamas tunnels, which are reportedly longer than the London tube system. Before these Israelis enter the tunnels, they are under orders to await the go-ahead of the Yahalom combat engineer unit, whose members are experts in tunnel warfare.

Advertisement 7

Article content

Two, the Israelis have been making use of technology that has protected them and civilians in a crowded urban environment. Their combat vehicles, for example, are nimble and more protective than any others in history. Meanwhile, their drones — “remotely piloted vehicles, “as the Israelis first called them and which the Israelis essentially invented 60 years ago — ensure that they target only Hamas and not civilians.

Three, there is the culture and mindset of the troops themselves. They have been trained, Luttwak said, to keep “fighting as hard and as long as necessary to grind down Hamas until nothing is left of its fighting strength.”

So is victory at hand? Is the war, which has cost the lives of many on both sides, almost over?

Advertisement 8

Article content

For the answer to that, my colleague Brian Lilley interviewed Eylon Levy, an official spokesperson for the Israeli government. (Their encounter will be on next week’s Postmedia podcast.)

Asked how the war is going, Levy was succinct: “For us, from Day 1, it has been very clear why we are fighting. We are fighting to bring the Hamas terror regime to justice, so that it can never again perpetrate again an atrocity like Oct. 7, and to bring back the hostages” he said.

“We are fighting for humanity. And anything less than a total victory will be a terrible danger to the whole free world.”

And that is the truth.

Article content

Source link

Denial of responsibility! NewsConcerns is an automatic aggregator of the all world’s media. In each content, the hyperlink to the primary source is specified. All trademarks belong to their rightful owners, all materials to their authors. If you are the owner of the content and do not want us to publish your materials, please contact us by email – [email protected]. The content will be deleted within 24 hours.

Leave a Comment